In-house legal
Briefing an external contract desk: the one-line intake that gets a usable redline
What to tell an external contract desk so the first redline comes back right: five facts, the playbook, and the two mistakes that cost a round.
An external desk is only as good as its brief. The good news is that a good brief is short. The desk does not need the history of the relationship or a memo on the deal; it needs five facts and a playbook. Everything else it can read in the document.
The five facts
Whose paper it is — yours, theirs, or a joint draft — because the posture of the redline follows from it. What the deal is, in one line: what is being bought or sold, for how much, for how long. The deadline, and whether it is real: “signature by the 30th” and “the business would like it soon” produce different redlines. The red lines: the two or three terms where there is no flexibility, named. The posture: how much the business wants this deal, which decides how hard to push and where to stop. A brief with those five facts fits in a Slack message. It should.
What the playbook does, so the brief does not have to
The playbook is the brief that was written once. It holds the positions on recurring terms — liability, payment, IP, data, termination, governing law — the acceptable fallbacks, the red lines and who decides what. With a playbook in place the per-document brief shrinks to the five facts above, and every redline is measured against the same standard. Without one, every brief has to restate the positions, and they drift. Building a playbook takes a 20-minute intake call and a few days of drafting; it is the highest-return time an in-house team spends with an external desk.
What not to put in the brief
A list of clauses to look at. The desk reads the whole document; a list of clauses tells it to read less. A proposed redline. If the team already knows what it wants changed, it has done the work; send the brief and let the desk do the drafting. A copy of the last negotiation. The desk will ask if it needs it; by default, the positions in the playbook are the memory.
The two mistakes that cost a round
Sending the document before the business has agreed what it wants. A redline against an unclear objective is a draft of a draft; the round that follows is spent discovering the objective. Hold the document a day and send a clear brief, and the first redline is usable. Giving the desk a deadline that is the business’s deadline, not the legal team’s. The desk returns short documents the next business day and longer ones within 48 hours, counted on business days, and the team needs a day to read the summary and decide the two or three decisions put to it; a brief that says “needed by Friday” when the business signs on Friday has already lost the review.
What comes back, and what to do with it
A redline with a comment on every change; a one-page summary with what changed, what was flagged, where the draft left the playbook and why, and the decisions that are the team’s to take, with the desk’s recommendation and alternatives; and, where asked, a cover note to the counterparty ready to send. The team reads the summary first, takes its decisions in the thread, and the document goes out. The document itself is read only if a decision depends on exact wording — which the summary says.
Next step
Have a contract like this on your desk?
Send it over on per-document terms. We will mark it up against your positions and walk your team through it.