Desk notes · In-house legal · Position of the week
Floating governing law — the clause that looks harmless
“This Agreement is governed by the laws of the Supplier’s country of incorporation.” It saves the supplier from having to redraft the clause for each buyer, and it looks like a neutral default. For the buyer it means the governing law is whatever the supplier’s corporate structure says it is — today, and after the supplier reorganises.
A buyer’s playbook names the law: its own home law by default, with one or two acceptable alternatives for suppliers who will not accept it — commonly English law, or the law of a neutral member state — and a named venue. A clause that points at a country without naming it is not a choice of law; it is a delegation of the choice to the other side. The same applies to “the courts of that country”: a venue the buyer cannot name is a venue the buyer has not agreed to.
When the supplier insists on its own law and the buyer is prepared to accept it to get the deal done, two things still need to happen. The law has to be named, so that both sides know what they have agreed; and the clauses that depend most on local law — delivery, risk and title, warranty, limitation — need to be read by a lawyer admitted in that law before signature, not after a dispute. That read is part of a desk review; it is not part of a template.
Next step
Seen something like this on your own paper?
Send it over. Twenty minutes, marked up, explained.