SaaS contracts

Liability caps in SaaS contracts, and what German law changes

In a SaaS agreement this clause sets the price of everything else. Negotiate it as a system of three parts, not as a single number, and check how it behaves under the governing law.

SaaS agreement § 12 Limitation of liability

12.2 The exclusions and limitations in this Section shall not apply to (a) a party’s breach of Section 8 (Confidentiality), (b) a party’s indemnification obligations under Section 11, and (c) Vendor’s breach of Section 9 (Data Protection), for which Vendor’s aggregate liability shall not exceed three (3) times the Fees paid in the preceding twelve (12) months.

Guide example § 12
In short
  • A liability cap is three things at once: a number, a list of exclusions and a list of carve-outs. The carve-outs decide how much you can actually lose or recover.
  • A super-cap, a higher but finite limit for data incidents, is the usual way to settle a customer's demand that data breaches be uncapped.
  • Before conceding any carve-out, check what it does to the indemnity: a broad indemnity outside the cap makes liability unlimited.
  • Under German law, standard terms cannot cap liability for intent or gross negligence. Draft the cap “so far as legally permissible”.

What the clause is made of

The clause has three parts, and negotiations stall when the parties treat it as one.

The cap. The most a party pays across all claims under the agreement. In SaaS the usual default is the fees paid or payable in the twelve months before the claim. Customers open with a higher multiple; vendors of low-priced products sometimes open with a fixed sum. A one-month cap, or a flat €90, is not a negotiating position: it shows the vendor has not negotiated this clause before.

The exclusions. Types of loss that neither party recovers whatever the cap says: indirect, consequential, special and punitive loss, lost profit and lost data. They are standard and mutual and seldom worth a round, with one exception covered below.

The carve-outs. Obligations that sit outside the cap, outside the exclusions, or both. This is where the negotiation happens.

The carve-outs, from most to least often conceded

Confidentiality — usually conceded

Breach of confidentiality is conventionally outside the cap. The loss it causes is usually indirect (lost business, reputational harm), so a vendor should check that the carve-out lifts the exclusions as well as the cap. If it lifts only the cap, it is hollow.

Indemnification obligations — usually conceded, with a condition

The indemnity for third-party IP infringement is normally uncapped. The vendor promises that the customer will not be sued for using the product, and that promise means little if it stops at twelve months of fees. The condition is that the indemnity is narrow. Uncapped cover for third-party IP claims is acceptable; uncapped cover for “any breach of this Agreement” is unlimited liability under another name.

Gross negligence and wilful misconduct — conceded

Standard and mutual, and in many jurisdictions it cannot be excluded in any case.

Data protection — the contested one

The customer says: a breach of our users’ data exposes us to regulators and claims, and twelve months of your fees is nothing against that. The vendor says: you are asking a €30k-a-year subscription to insure your entire regulatory exposure. Both are right, which is why the market settled on the super-cap: a separate, higher limit for data-protection breaches, typically two to five times annual fees and sometimes a fixed sum tied to the vendor’s cyber insurance. The customer gets real recourse and the vendor gets a figure it can insure.

Payment obligations — always carved out, never disputed

The customer’s duty to pay fees is outside the cap on the customer’s side. Without that, a customer could stop paying and rely on the cap.

In EU deals: German law and standard terms

Where the contract is governed by German law and the cap sits in standard terms, § 309 BGB limits what can be excluded. Liability for intent and gross negligence cannot be limited, nor can liability for ordinary negligence causing injury to life, body or health, and damage from breach of a “cardinal obligation” is treated strictly. A cap drafted on English-law habits can be struck down entirely, leaving no cap at all. The practical answer is to draft the cap “soweit gesetzlich zulässig” (so far as legally permissible), with the mandatory categories carved out explicitly. This is a point where we bring in German counsel. The full treatment is in the German enterprise MSA guide.

The exclusion that deserves a second look

“Loss of data” sits on most vendor exclusion lists. For a SaaS product whose whole purpose is to hold the customer’s data, excluding liability for losing it is a hard ask, and informed customers will strike it. A defensible vendor position excludes loss of data to the extent the customer did not keep its own backups or the loss comes from the customer’s configuration, and puts the rest under the super-cap.

How it interacts with everything else

If you concede…Check…
An indemnity outside the capThat it covers only third-party IP claims (and perhaps confidentiality). Otherwise the cap no longer means anything.
Data breach uncappedYour cyber insurance limit. With a €2m policy, uncapped exposure on a €50k contract is a problem the contract itself created.
A higher general capWhether it is mutual. Customers sometimes ask for the higher cap on the vendor only.
A carve-out for “breach of Section X”What Section X says today, and whether the customer can change it through an order form.

A workable vendor position

  • General cap: twelve months of fees, mutual.
  • Exclusions: indirect and consequential loss, mutual; loss of data limited to the customer’s own failures.
  • Outside the cap: confidentiality, IP indemnity, gross negligence and wilful misconduct, payment.
  • Super-cap for data-protection breaches: three times annual fees, or the insured amount if higher.
  • Walk-away: uncapped liability for breach of contract generally, and any carve-out that refers to a clause the customer controls.
The mistake we see most

The common mistake is conceding carve-outs one at a time over three rounds, each for something unrelated. By round three nobody remembers that the indemnity was widened in round one, and the cap covers nothing that matters.

General information, not legal advice. This page describes how EU and cross-border commercial contracts commonly work; it is not advice on your situation, and no engagement arises until a service agreement with Icon.Partners is signed. For advice on a specific contract, speak to a lawyer qualified in the relevant jurisdiction.

Next step

Have a contract like this on your desk?

Send it over. We will mark it up and walk you through it in twenty minutes — no cost, and you will know whether the desk is worth it.

Book a contract call