Process

A contract redline checklist for EU B2B deals

A checklist does not replace judgment. It keeps judgment from being spent on what does not need it, so it is free for what does. This one adds the points that matter when the deal is European.

Services agreement § 14 Survival

14.1 Sections 6 (Fees), 8 (Confidentiality), 9 (Limitation of Liability), 11 (Indemnification) and 13 (Governing Law) shall survive termination or expiry of this Agreement.

Guide example § 14
In short
  • Review in four passes (commercial, risk, operational, drafting) and not from top to bottom.
  • Definitions and precedence clauses change the meaning of everything else, so read them last on purpose.
  • The costliest defects are usually the quiet ones: an auto-renewal, a survival clause, a missing cure period.
  • In EU deals also check payment terms against the Late Payment Directive, the governing law, and the order of precedence over the buyer’s purchasing terms.

Pass one: the commercial terms

Do the numbers in the document match the deal that was agreed? It sounds obvious and is missed all the time.

  • Fees, currency, payment terms and late payment interest. Inside the EU, ninety days from invoice is on the edge of what Directive 2011/7 permits; thirty days from receipt of a valid invoice is the workable position, with the undisputed part payable even if a line is queried.
  • Term, start date, and whether the start is signature, delivery or go-live.
  • Renewal: automatic or not, the notice period, and any cap on price increases.
  • Scope: what is being bought, in enough detail to settle a dispute about it from the document alone.
  • Volume or usage limits, and what happens on overage.

Pass two: the risk allocation

  • Limitation of liability — the cap, the exclusions and the carve-outs from both. Where German law governs standard terms, check the standard-terms limits.
  • Indemnities — who gives what, for what, and whether they sit inside or outside the cap.
  • Warranties — what is promised about the product or service, and the remedy if the promise is broken.
  • Data protection — the DPA attached or incorporated, the transfer mechanism addressed (see SCCs and the UK addendum), and a breach notice timing you can meet.
  • Insurance — the cover required, and whether you hold it.
  • Intellectual property — ownership of pre-existing IP, deliverables, feedback, derived data.

Pass three: the operational terms

These clauses decide whether the relationship works day to day, and they are the ones most often accepted unread.

  • Termination — for cause with a cure period, for convenience if at all, for insolvency, and what follows on exit.
  • Service levels — the commitment, the measurement window, the remedy and whether it is exclusive.
  • Support — hours, channels, response and resolution targets.
  • Change control — how scope changes are agreed and priced.
  • Assignment — whether either party can assign, and whether a change of control counts.
  • Subcontracting — permitted, and on what notice.
  • Notices — current addresses and a method that will actually be read.

Pass four: the drafting

Only now, with the substance clear, read the parts that change what it means.

  • Definitions. Does “Confidential Information”, “Services” or “Fees” mean what the body of the document assumes it means? A narrow definition of Services can turn a broad warranty into a hollow one.
  • Order of precedence. Which document wins when the MSA, the order form and the SLA disagree. In an EU deal put the buyer’s general purchasing terms last, expressly excluded where they conflict: see the German enterprise MSA guide.
  • Survival. Which clauses continue after termination. Confidentiality, liability, indemnity and payment should. A survival clause that lists only three of the four is a defect.
  • Entire agreement. Does it cancel the promises the sales team relied on to close?
  • Cross-references. Every “subject to clause 14.2” should point at a clause 14.2 that says what the drafter thought it said. Renumbering during negotiation breaks these silently.
  • Blanks and brackets. Search the document for “[” and “TBD” before signing. It catches something more often than you would like.
Write the summary before the redline

Before you mark anything up, write three lines: what matters most in this deal, what we would concede, what we would not sign. The redline then serves the summary, and the person who approves it reads a note in a minute instead of forty tracked changes with no explanation.

General information, not legal advice. This page describes how EU and cross-border commercial contracts commonly work; it is not advice on your situation, and no engagement arises until a service agreement with Icon.Partners is signed. For advice on a specific contract, speak to a lawyer qualified in the relevant jurisdiction.

Next step

Have a contract like this on your desk?

Send it over. We will mark it up and walk you through it in twenty minutes — no cost, and you will know whether the desk is worth it.

Book a contract call